An OCR (Office for Civil Rights) audit is one of the most stressful events a healthcare organization can face. The process is thorough, the documentation requirements are extensive, and the consequences of identified violations can be severe—ranging from corrective action plans to multi-million dollar settlements and consent decrees.
However, organizations that maintain ongoing HIPAA compliance and proper documentation can navigate OCR audits successfully. The key is preparation: having your compliance house in order before an audit notice arrives, not scrambling to create documentation after the fact.
Critical Timeline
When OCR sends an audit request, you typically have 10 business days to respond with comprehensive documentation. This is not enough time to create policies, conduct risk analysis, or develop training programs. You must have these in place already.
Breaches affecting 500+ individuals almost always trigger an investigation. Smaller breaches may be selected for compliance review.
OCR receives thousands of complaints annually. Complex or egregious complaints often lead to investigations.
OCR conducts periodic random audits across healthcare sectors. Any covered entity can be selected.
Healthcare data breaches or privacy violations that receive media attention typically trigger OCR scrutiny.
State health departments, CMS, or other federal agencies may refer cases to OCR for investigation.
Key Insight: While you can't prevent breaches or complaints entirely, you can control your compliance posture. Organizations with strong compliance programs typically receive lighter penalties and faster resolution even when incidents occur.
Based on OCR enforcement actions and audit protocols, these are the areas where violations are most commonly found.
The foundation of the Security Rule. OCR wants to see a comprehensive, documented risk assessment.
Common Deficiencies OCR Finds:
OCR consistently finds BAA violations. Every vendor handling PHI must have a signed, compliant BAA.
Common Deficiencies OCR Finds:
Unauthorized access to PHI is a leading cause of violations. OCR scrutinizes who can access what data.
Common Deficiencies OCR Finds:
While technically 'addressable', OCR expects encryption for ePHI unless documented justification exists.
Common Deficiencies OCR Finds:
HIPAA requires documented policies for all Privacy and Security Rule requirements.
Common Deficiencies OCR Finds:
All workforce members must be trained on privacy and security policies upon hire and regularly thereafter.
Common Deficiencies OCR Finds:
OCR will request extensive documentation. Have these organized and readily accessible.
Documentation Best Practice
Maintain a "compliance binder" (physical or digital) with all HIPAA documentation organized by category. Update it continuously, not just before audits. HIPAA requires 6-year retention for all compliance records.
A step-by-step guide to managing the OCR audit process from notification to resolution.
Real OCR enforcement actions and what they teach us about audit preparation.
Anchorage Community Mental Health Services - $150,000 settlement
Lesson:
Risk analysis is the foundation of Security Rule compliance. You must conduct and document it.
Anthem Inc. - $16 million settlement (included BAA issues)
Lesson:
Every business associate must have a compliant, signed BAA before PHI disclosure.
New York Presbyterian Hospital - $2.2 million settlement for filming with ABC
Lesson:
Obtain patient authorization before any non-permitted disclosure, including media.
Cornell Prescription Pharmacy - $125,000 for unencrypted laptop theft
Lesson:
Encrypt devices containing ePHI or document why it's unreasonable and implement alternatives.
MD Anderson Cancer Center - $4.3 million for unencrypted devices and access issues
Lesson:
Implement role-based access controls and terminate access promptly when no longer needed.
Banner Health - $1.25 million for delayed breach reporting to OCR
Lesson:
Report breaches affecting 500+ individuals to OCR within 60 days, not 'as soon as possible.'
The best audit preparation is ongoing compliance. Build these activities into your annual schedule.
Learn about the top HIPAA violations that lead to fines and penalties, and discover practical prevention strategies.
Read ArticleNew to HIPAA? Learn the fundamentals of HIPAA compliance, who it applies to, and essential requirements.
Read Article